Archives
 
 
 
  Special
 
 
 
  About Us
 
 
 

Newsletter
Free E-mail Newsletter from BYTE.com

 
    
           
Visit the home page Browse the four-year online archive Download platform-neutral CPU/FPU benchmarks Find information for advertisers, authors, vendors, subscribers Request free information on products written about or advertised in BYTE Submit a press release, or scan recent announcements Talk with BYTE's staff and readers about products and technologies

ArticlesEISA 486s For Windows


April 1994 / BYTE Lab Product Report / EISA 486s For Windows

Out of the 37 486s we tested, 11 came with an EISA-bus architecture. EISA systems cost an average of $1400 more than a similarly equipped ISA system (however, some EISA prices reflect a configuration of 32 MB versus 16 MB in the ISA category). The high-performance EISA 486s even averaged about $500 more than ISA-based Pentiums. (EISA Pentiums cost $8000, on average.)

Also, out of the 11 EISA-based machines, 10 supported VL-Bus; the exception was AST Research's Premmia 4/66d, Model 343M, the first runner-up in Best Overall, which uses a proprietary local-bus design.

Despite the higher cost of EISA systems, we found little performance advantage in our Windows tests. For example, Cornell Computer Systems sent 486s that outran all others in our ISA and EISA Windows tests. The ISA-based Cornell Power Pak posted a Wind ows score of 2.04 versus the Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2's leading score of 1.91. The faster speed overall in the ISA systems may be attributed partly to faster video systems in those machines. (The Weitek P9000 powered the Cornell ISA-based system and the Tseng Labs W32i accelerated the Cornell EISA system.)


Rankings for This Category Considered



PERFORMANCE     60%
EASE OF USE     30%
FEATURES        10%




For the best in speed and usability...



BEST OVERALL
Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2
This EISA system earned a Windows performance index of 1.91, the highest among systems ranked in this category and almost twice as fast as our baseline system. Besides scoring high in our performance tests, this system is also easy to use and offers a 16550 UART (universal asynchronous receiver/transmitter) for fast serial communication, as well as flash ROM for easy BIOS updates. The system sells for an economical price under $4500. The AST Premmia's Windows score
 of 1.87 nearly matches the Cornell's, and the Premmia also earned the best features rating in the category. This is the EISA machine to buy if you're looking for the best desktop-case system.


                                                 CASE      WINDOWS    EASE
                                       PRICE     TYPE      SPEED      OF USE
BEST      Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2       $3995       B       1.91       ****
RUNNER-UP AST Premmia 4/66d            $6862       A       1.87       ****
RUNNER-UP Micron 466 VLE WinServer     $4498       B       1.80       ****
RUNNER-UP CompuAdd C466De              $5806       B       1.78       ***
RUNNER-UP MIS Computer Systems M466EV  $4451       B       1.76       ***


                                       FEATURES                RAM (MB)
                                       SCORE      BUS          STD./MAX.
BEST      Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2       6.14       EISA/VL      32/256
RUNNER-UP AST Premmia 4/66d            6.25       EISA/Prop.   32/12
8
RUNNER-UP Micron 466 VLE WinServer     5.29       EISA/VL      32/64
RUNNER-UP CompuAdd C466De              4.88       EISA/VL      16/128
RUNNER-UP MIS Computer Systems M466EV  4.81       EISA/VL      32/64


                                       HARD         WARRANTY
                                       DRIVE (MB)   (MONTHS)    VIDEO
BEST      Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2       1024/SCSI    36          Tseng W32i
RUNNER-UP AST Premmia 4/66d            1024/SCSI    36          ATI Mach 32
RUNNER-UP Micron 466 VLE WinServer     540/SCSI     Lifetime    Weitek P9000
RUNNER-UP CompuAdd C466De              1024/SCSI    12          ATI Mach 32
RUNNER-UP MIS Computer Systems M466EV  1024/SCSI    12          Weitek


Key
Ease of Use:
Poor      *
Fair      **
Good      ***
Excellent ****
Case:
Desktop    A
Tower      B
Mini-tower C
Prop = proprietary.




Need growth potential?



MOST EXPANDABLE
Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2
In addition to its superior perfo
rmance, this huge tower also supplies growing room: It offers two 3 1/2-inch drive bays and four 5 1/4-inch drive bays, along with three available EISA slots and one VL-Bus slot. CompuAdd's C466De Mini Tower posted the second-highest speed scores. Its sturdy tower chassis supports four 3 1/2-inch and three 5 1/4-inch drives. Five 32-bit EISA and one VL-Bus expansion slot were available for additional cards.


                                                 CASE      WINDOWS    EASE
                                       PRICE     TYPE      SPEED      OF USE
BEST      Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2       $3995       B       1.91       ****
RUNNER-UP CompuAdd C466De              $5806       B       1.78       ***
RUNNER-UP Micro Express MicroFlex      $4800       B       1.76       ****
RUNNER-UP MIS Computer Systems M466EV  $4451       B       1.76       ***
RUNNER-UP DEC DECpc 466 MTE            $5715       B       1.67       ****


                                       FEATURES                 RAM
 (MB)
                                       SCORE      BUS           STD./MAX.
BEST      Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2       6.14       EISA/VL       32/256
RUNNER-UP CompuAdd C466De              4.88       EISA/VL       16/128
RUNNER-UP Micro Express MicroFlex      3.51       EISA/VL       32/128
RUNNER-UP MIS Computer Systems M466EV  4.81       EISA/VL       32/64
RUNNER-UP DEC DECpc 466 MTE            5.56       EISA/VL       32/128


                                     OPEN BAYS     WARRANTY
                                   3 1/2 - 5 1/4   (MONTHS)    VIDEO
BEST      Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2       2 - 4           4       Tseng W32i
RUNNER-UP CompuAdd C466De              2 - 2           6       ATI Mach 32
RUNNER-UP Micro Express MicroFlex      4 - 4           8       Tseng W32i
RUNNER-UP MIS Computer Systems M466EV  2 - 4           4       Weitek
RUNNER-UP DEC DECpc 466 MTE            0 - 2           4       N/A


Key
Ease of Use:
Poor      *
Fair      **
Good      ***
Excellent ****

Case:
Desktop    A
Tower      B
Mini-tower C
Prop = proprietary.
N/A = not available




When you need speed and economy...



LOW COST
Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2
Fast performance, excellent features, and a price below the average of $4900 enabled this system to sweep our categories for EISA-based 486s. If your budget requires an EISA system that is less expensive than the Cornell and you can settle for slower Windows performance, consider the American Multisystems' Info Gold E-Server, the least expensive system we ranked in this class.


                                                CASE      WINDOWS    EASE
                                      PRICE     TYPE      SPEED      OF USE
BEST      Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2      $3995       B       1.91       ****
RUNNER-UP AMS Info Gold E-Server      $3499       B       1.66       ***
RUNNER-UP MIS Computer Systems M466EV $4451       B       1.76       ***
RUNNER-UP Micro Express MicroFlex     $4800       B       1.
76       ****


                                      FEATURES                 RAM (MB)
                                      SCORE      BUS           STD./MAX.
BEST      Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2      6.14       EISA/VL       32/256
RUNNER-UP AMS Info Gold E-Server      4.30       EISA/VL       32/256
RUNNER-UP MIS Computer Systems M466EV 4.81       EISA/VL       32/64
RUNNER-UP Micro Express MicroFlex     3.51       EISA/VL       32/128


                                      HARD         WARRANTY
                                      DRIVE (MB)   (MONTHS)    VIDEO
BEST      Cornell EISA-VL SCSI-2      1024/SCSI       36       Tseng W32i
RUNNER-UP AMS Info Gold E-Server      1024/SCSI       12       S3 805
RUNNER-UP MIS Computer Systems M466EV 1024/SCSI       12       Weitek
RUNNER-UP Micro Express MicroFlex     1024/SCSI       24       Tseng W32i


Key
Ease of Use:
Poor      *
Fair      **
Good      ***
Excellent ****
Case:
Desktop    A
Tower      B
Mini-tower C
Prop = propr
ietary.


Up to the BYTE Lab Product Report section contentsGo to previous article: ISA 486s For WindowsGo to next article: 486s For UnixSearchSend a comment on this articleSubscribe to BYTE or BYTE on CD-ROM  
Flexible C++
Matthew Wilson
My approach to software engineering is far more pragmatic than it is theoretical--and no language better exemplifies this than C++.

more...

BYTE Digest

BYTE Digest editors every month analyze and evaluate the best articles from Information Week, EE Times, Dr. Dobb's Journal, Network Computing, Sys Admin, and dozens of other CMP publications—bringing you critical news and information about wireless communication, computer security, software development, embedded systems, and more!

Find out more

BYTE.com Store

BYTE CD-ROM
NOW, on one CD-ROM, you can instantly access more than 8 years of BYTE.
 
The Best of BYTE Volume 1: Programming Languages
The Best of BYTE
Volume 1: Programming Languages
In this issue of Best of BYTE, we bring together some of the leading programming language designers and implementors...

Copyright © 2005 CMP Media LLC, Privacy Policy, Your California Privacy rights, Terms of Service
Site comments: webmaster@byte.com
SDMG Web Sites: BYTE.com, C/C++ Users Journal, Dr. Dobb's Journal, MSDN Magazine, New Architect, SD Expo, SD Magazine, Sys Admin, The Perl Journal, UnixReview.com, Windows Developer Network