Jump to...
Columns:
Advanced Software and Technologies
BYTE Media Lab
Chaos Manor
Conference Reports
Features
Free Features
Gigglebytes
Letters to BYTE.com
Mr. Computer Language Person
New Products
Op/Ed
Portable Computing
Serving with Linux
The Upgrade Advisor
Features Table
August 1997
/
BYTE Hardware Lab Report
/ Features Table
Apple Newton MessagePad 2000
Casio Cassiopeia A-11 Plus
Compaq Computer PC Companion (C140)
Hewlett-Packard HP 320LX Palmtop PC
Hitachi SH3 Handheld PC HPW-10E4MB
Price as tested (MSRP)
$1099 (includes keyboard, case, and software)
$689
$479
$699
$599
Overall rating
***
**
***
*****
***
PROCESSOR
Manufacturer and model
StrongARM SA-110
Hitachi SH3
Hitachi SH3
Hitachi SH3
Hitachi SH3
Operating system
Newton 2.1 OS
Windows CE
Windows CE
Windows CE
Windows CE
SCREEN
Resolution (dpi)
480 x 320
480 x 240
480 x 240
640 x 240
480 x 240
Screen area (inches)
4.9 x 3.3
4 x 2
4 x 2
6.3 x 2.5
5 x 2
On-screen function icons
DATA ENTRY
Touchscreen with pen stylus navigation
*
*
*
*
*
Keypad
External
*
*
*
*
Both
*
*
*
*
*
Handwriting recognition software included
*
On-screen keyboard
*
CASE
Height x width x depth (inches)
1.1 x 4.7 x 8.3
1 x 6 x 3
1 x 6.8 x 3.6
1.1 x 7.2 x 3.6
1 x 6.58 x 3.78
Weight
1.4 lbs. (including batteries)
13.4 oz. (incl. batteries)
13.4 oz. (inc
l. batteries)
15.6 oz. (incl. batteries)
13.6 oz. (incl. batteries)
MEMORY
Amount of RAM
5 MB
6 MB
4 MB
4 MB
4 MB
BUILT-IN FUNCTIONS
Word processor
*
*
*
*
*
Spreadsheet
*
*
*
*
Standard features ++
*
*
*
*
*
Sketch/paintbrush
*
Optional capture
*
*
*
Alarm clock
*
*
Games
*
*
*
*
Expense filer
*
Financial management
Pager
Optional
*
Internet access/Web browser
*
*
*
*
*
Faxing
*
*
*
*
*
E-mail
*
*
*
*
*
COMMUNICATIONS
Interface cable included
*
*
*
*
*
Printer link
*
Optional
*
PC Card-compatible
*
*
*
*
*
Other
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
MODEM
On-board modem
*
PC Card modem available
*
*
*
*
Speed
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
28.8-Kbps
INFRARED PORT
IR port included
*
*
*
*
*
File transfer range (distance)
3.2 feet
3 feet
3 feet
3 feet
50 cm
Data transfer speed
115.2-Kbps
115.2-Kbps
115.2-Kbps
115.2-Kbps
115.2 Kbps
DOCKING STATION
Docking station required for HPC/PC connectivity
SOUND
External sound-recording/playback capabilities
*
Integrated speaker
*
*
*
*
*
POWER SUPPLIES
AC power adapter
*
Optional
Optional
*
*
Battery type
4 AA
2 AA
2 AA
2 AA
2 AA
Does AC adapter have a battery recharger?
*
No (rechargeable battery pack available)
Optional
* (through docking station)
Backup batteries/type
NimH
Lithium
NimH (optional)
NiCad
Lithium
Estimated battery life without PC Card
3-6 weeks
20 hours
20 hours
4-6 weeks
12 hours
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
Toll-free telephone
800-462-4396
800-96-CASIO
800-652-6672
800-443-1254
800-HITACHI
Phone
408-996-1010
888-204-7765
287-370-0670
970-392-1001
On-line address
http://www.newton.apple/connect
http://www.casio.com
http://www.compaq.com
http://www.hp.com/handheld
http://www.hitachi-ce.com
Inquiry number
980
981
982
983
984
KEY:
BB
= BYTE Best; * = yes; ***** Outstanding, **** Very Good, *** Good, ** Fair, * Poor; + Can add 16 MB of RAM, ++ Standard features = Database/contact manager and agenda/organizer/synchronization software, +++ Can use standard PC Card with adapter
BB:
NEC Computer Systems MobilePro 450
Philips Consumer Electronics Velo 1
BB:
Psion Series 3C
Sharp Zaurus ZR-5800 FX
U.S. Robotics
Palm Pilot Professional
Price as tested (MSRP)
$499
$699
$399
$599
$399
Overall rating
****
****
*****
****
****
PROCESSOR
Manufacturer and model
NEC Vr4101
Philips R3910
NEC V30H
Motorola Dragon Chip
Motorola 68328
Operating system
Windows CE
Windows CE
Psion EPOC 16
Zaurus Synergy
Palm OS
SCREEN
Resolution (dpi)
480 x 240
480 x 240
480 x 160
320 x 240
160 x 160
Screen area (inches)
4.5 x 2.2
5 x 2
5 x 2
4 x 2.7
2.5 x 3.25
On-screen function icons
*
*
*
DATA ENTRY
Touchscreen with pen stylus navigation
*
*
*
*
Keypad
*
*
*
*
Both
*
*
*
Handwriting recognition software included
*
Keyboard-driven
*
On-screen keyboard
*
CASE
Height x width x depth (inches)
1.07x 6.89 x3.74
1.25 x 6.75 x 3.75
6.5 x 3.35 x 0.87
1 x 6.7 x 3.9
0.7 x 3.2 x 4.7
Weight
0.88 lbs. (incl. batteries)
13.2 oz. (not incl. batteries)
9.7 oz. (incl. batteries)
14.7 oz. (incl. batteries)
5.7 oz.(incl. batteries)
MEMORY
Amount of RAM
4 MB
4 MB
2 MB+
2 MB
1 MB
BUILT-IN FUNCTIONS
Word processor
*
*
*
*
Spreadsheet
*
*
*
*
Standard features ++
*
*
*
*
*
Sketch/paintbrush
*
*
*
Alarm clock
*
*
*
Games
*
*
*
*
Expense filer
*
Optional
*
Financial management
Optional
Pager
Optional
Internet access/Web browser
*
*
Optional
Faxing
*
*
Optional
E-mail
*
*
Optional
Optional
*
COMMUNICATIONS
Interface cable included
*
*
*
*
Printer link
1 (via b2 software)
No (via desktop)
* (cable/wireless)
No (via desktop apps)
PC Card-compatible
*
Mini PC Card +++
* (via adapter)
*
No
Other
N/A
N/A
OVAL
Wireless e-mail
N/A
MODEM
O
n-board modem
*
* (snap-on modem)
PC Card modem available
*
*
*
*
No
Speed
N/A
19.2-Kbps
N/A
N/A
14.4-Kbps
INFRARED PORT
IR port included
*
*
*
*
File transfer range (distance)
8-12 inches
2 meters
3 feet
20 inches
N/A
Data transfer speed
115.2 Kbps
115.2 Kbps
115.2 Kbps
115.2 Kbps
N/A
DOCKING STATION
Docking station required for HPC/PC connectivity
*
*
*
SOUND
External sound-recording/playback capabilities
*
*
Integrated speaker
*
*
*
POWER SUPPLIES
AC power adapter
*
*
Optional
Optional
Battery type
2 AA
2 AA
2 AA
2 AA
2 AAA
Does AC adapter have a battery recharger?
Optional
Optional
N/A
Backup batteries/type
3-V lithium
Lithium
Lithium
Lithium
Estimated battery lif
e without PC Card
30 hours
15 hours
80 hours (PC Card attachment is self-powered)
100 hours
2 months
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
Toll-free telephone
800-632-4525
888-367-8356
800-99PSION
800-BE-SHARP
800-881-7256
Phone
508-264-8000
408-523-2800
508-371-0310
201-529-8700
415-237-6000
On-line address
http://www.nec-computers.com
http://www.velo1.com
http://www.psion.com
http://www.sharp-usa.com
http://www.usr.com/palm
Inquiry number
985
986
987
988
989
KEY:
BB
= BYTE Best; * = yes; ***** Outstanding, **** Very Good, *** Good, ** Fair, * Poor; + Can add 16 MB of RAM, ++ Standard features = Database/contact manager and agenda/organizer/synchronization software, +++ Can use standard PC Card with adapter
Matthew Wilson
My approach to software engineering is far more pragmatic than it
is
theoretical--and no language better exemplifies this than C++.
more...
BYTE Digest editors every month analyze and evaluate the best articles from Information Week , EE Times , Dr. Dobb's Journal , Network Computing , Sys Admin ,
and dozens of other CMP publications—bringing
you critical news and information about wireless communication,
computer security, software development, embedded systems,
and more!
Find out more